The hidden split
Guests assume every pound they bid goes to the charity. In my experience, on most occasions only a small fraction does, and sometimes almost none. The gap is rarely disclosed to anyone.
Insights/How to choose a silent auction company
I built this business because of what I kept seeing other companies do to charities. So this is not a neutral guide to choosing a silent auction company. It is an honest one, from someone who has stood in a lot of these rooms and watched the money quietly leak away.

If you are hiring a silent auction company, the polish of the brochure tells you nothing. What matters is where the money goes, and most of the industry is very good at making sure you never quite work that out. Here is what to look for.
If you would rather not hire anyone, read how to run a silent auction in-house: donated lots, phone bidding, and every pound kept by the charity.
The one question that decides everything
Ask it early. Ask for the answer in writing. Then watch how quickly it arrives. Every tactic below is a way of making that number smaller while keeping it hidden.
A silent auction company supplies some mix of three things: the lots, the technology, and the people to run it. At one end are software-only platforms. At the other are full-service firms that arrive with a catalogue of prizes, staff and a brochure, and run the whole thing for you.
The full-service end is where the money questions get most important, because the company is not just charging a fee, it is often the source of the prizes too. When the same company supplies the lots, sets the prices and runs the bidding, it controls almost every number that decides what your charity keeps. That is not automatically a problem. It means you have to look hard at the incentives, because they are rarely pointed where you would hope.
As at 2 November 2026, the main UK silent auction suppliers fall into software you run yourself (GalaBid, Jumblebee, momoGood, Emma Live) and managed services that bring prizes and staff (A Star Experience, Superstars, Impulse Decisions). Each is paid differently: tips, a percentage, a quote, a per-event fee, or a margin inside the reserve.
| Supplier | What it supplies | Paid from, in its own words | Read |
|---|---|---|---|
| GalaBid | Software for silent and live auctions, raffles and ticketing. It does not supply an auctioneer. | A free plan funded by optional tips at checkout, with 10% of tips shared back to the cause; a Pro plan at a 4.9% fee; or a flat fee of US$1,250 per campaign. Its page says it does not hold your funds. | 2 Nov 2026 |
| Jumblebee | Online auctions (beeClassic), mobile bidding at your event (beeFree) and an on-site team with iPads (beePro). | beeClassic 5% plus VAT. beeFree shows no platform fees but must include 10 or more of its Buzz items. beePro is a fixed fee, not published. Optional payment collection adds 2.4% plus 20p. | 2 Nov 2026 |
| momoGood (formerly Givergy) | Auction software, with optional managed services, auctioneer coordination and item sourcing. | A quote based on guest count, features and support level. It says it takes no percentage of what you raise. Sourced items are consigned at no upfront cost. | 2 Nov 2026 |
| Emma Live | Auction, ticketing and pledge software with a direct Stripe link. | Emma Essential has a 4% platform fee and no upfront fee, with an optional donor tip. Emma Enhanced starts at £1,295 for a single event. Emma Annual is a bespoke proposal. | 2 Nov 2026 |
| A Star Experience | Managed silent auctions with its own items, using tablets, QR codes or paper brochures. | Advertised as a free service. Its FAQ says cost follows a sliding scale by how many of its items you include, with a minimum bid price per item and 100% of any amount above it going to the charity. | 2 Nov 2026 |
| Superstars | Its own stock of lots, an account manager, an electronic bidding platform or a printed brochure, and an on-site team. | For its items, a supply price it keeps, with the charity keeping everything above it. Donated items are kept 100%. It says it transfers funds within four weeks of collecting payments. | 2 Nov 2026 |
| Impulse Decisions | A managed silent auction with printed brochures and sealed bids, run by its team. | Described as free to the charity, with, in its words, all fees built into the reserve prices. | 2 Nov 2026 |
| Generosity Works (this site) | An auctioneer and host who brings the platform with the booking. | The platform is free when a charity books Kevin as auctioneer and host. His fee is the only money taken, and it is not sold on its own. | Our own answers |
Every row except the last comes from the supplier’s own page, opened on 2 November 2026. I have repeated claims in their words, not tested them. Pricing changes, so check the live page. Superstars and Impulse Decisions publish no fee figure, and the A Star Experience terms above come from its FAQ, which makes the free service conditional. Before you sign with any of them, ask the question in the next section.
Silent auction companies charge in four ways: a percentage of winning bids, a fixed fee per event, a tip asked of each bidder, or a margin built into the reserve of consigned lots. On a £10,000 auction, the arithmetic below runs from nothing out of the charity’s pocket to more than £1,000, depending on the model.
| Fee model | How it works | The sum at £10,000 | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Percentage of winning bids | A set share of every winning bid, sometimes plus VAT. | 5% plus VAT at 20% is £500 plus £100, so £600. A 4% fee is £400. | Jumblebee beeClassic and Emma Essential rates, 2 Nov 2026 |
| Per-event fixed fee | One price whatever the total. | £1,295 whether the night raises £10,000 or £50,000, which is 12.95% of the smaller figure and 2.59% of the larger. | Emma Enhanced, from £1,295 for a single event, 2 Nov 2026 |
| Tip | Bidders are asked to add a tip to the supplier at checkout. | In GalaBid’s own example, £10,000 raised draws $1,000 in tips from participants, and $100 comes back to the cause as its 10% share. | GalaBid pricing page, 2 Nov 2026 (its example is in dollars) |
| Consignment margin | The supplier supplies the lot and sets a reserve above its cost. The charity receives only bids above the reserve. | An example lot costing the supplier £100 with a £400 reserve that sells at £400 sends £0 to the charity and £400 to the supplier. If it sells at £450, the charity receives £50. | My own illustration, not a named supplier, as used earlier on this page |
Neither a percentage nor a fixed fee is wrong, but they are different bets: a percentage grows with a good night, a fixed fee shrinks as a share of it. The tip model moves the cost onto your guests. The consignment margin is the hardest to see, because it sits inside a reserve and not on an invoice. Whichever you choose, ask for the total the charity will receive on a £10,000 night, in writing.
The fifth route is the one I can speak for. The Generosity Works platform is free when a charity books me as its auctioneer and host, my fee is the only money taken, and it is one fee agreed up front with no percentage and no tip prompt. You can book me through thecharityauctioneer.uk. For a small online-only auction with no live element, a software-only supplier from the table above may well be the right call.
None of these is unusual. Most of them are standard practice. That is the point.
Guests assume every pound they bid goes to the charity. In my experience, on most occasions only a small fraction does, and sometimes almost none. The gap is rarely disclosed to anyone.
Many companies run the auction under the charity’s own name and branding, and never volunteer that they are a separate, for-profit business taking a margin on every lot. A guest handing over £400 believes they gave £400 to the cause.
The company sets a reserve well above what the lot cost it. That gap is its profit, taken first. The charity only ever sees money bid above the reserve.
A hundred lots and two hundred guests is two bidders per lot. No competition, so most lots sell at the reserve, which is exactly where the company’s margin lives.
Keeping the silent auction running through the live auction and the pledge leaves guests glued to their phones, holding money back, at the exact moment the room’s biggest gifts are asked for.
Tips added to donor payments that the platform mostly keeps. A percentage of everything raised. Your money held in their account. Your donor data kept as theirs. Legal, all of it, and rarely spelled out.
Presenting a commercial operation as if it were the charity is misleading, and the Fundraising Regulator’s code is clear that fundraising must be open and honest about who is asking and where the money goes.
Usually far less than the hammer price, because the reserve is set to protect the company’s margin, not your cause. Here is the mechanism, with two lots I have watched go under the hammer.
In each case the company pockets the difference between the cost and the reserve, and the charity only receives whatever a guest bids on top. If the lot sells at the reserve, the charity gets nothing at all from it, while the company banks its margin in full. This is the same arithmetic we set out in our guide to the items to avoid, and it is why a donated lot, kept in full, so often beats a glossy bought-in one. The moment that wins that money in the room is the live pledge: people come to a fundraiser to make a difference, not to buy a shiny lot, so a well-run live pledge gives every guest a way to give.
Almost always the opposite. A brochure stuffed with a hundred lots looks generous and works against your charity. Think about the maths in the room.
Two bidders per lot means no competition, no bidding war, and no pressure to go one more. Most lots simply sell at, or close to, the reserve. And selling at the reserve is fine by the company, because its profit is already baked into that reserve. It does not need competition to make its money. Your charity does, because your money is the bit on top, and the bit on top is exactly what a hundred-lot brochure smothers.
A company working for the charity would run fewer, better lots, so each one drew real competition and climbed well above any reserve. A company working for itself fills the brochure, because volume at the reserve suits it perfectly. There is more on closing before the live auction in our note on silent auction closing rules.
Ask the questions that expose the arithmetic, and ask for the answers in writing. A company that is genuinely on your side will not flinch at any of them.
A good one is transparent to the point of being boring about money. Put the usual approach next to what you should insist on, and the difference is not subtle.
That is the standard we built Generosity Works to meet, and it is the practical half of the belief behind everything we do. We run the auction in-house, we never take a cut of the giving, and the platform is free when you book me as your auctioneer and host. Our numbers are on our pricing page, and there is nothing on it that moves with what your room gives.
No obligation, and never a percentage of what you raise
Choosing a silent auction company is not about who has the shiniest catalogue. It is about who will be honest with you, and with your guests, about where the money goes. Ask the one question, ask for it in writing, and watch how quickly the answer arrives.
Book a discovery call→